How to Hear God’s Voice (Without Overthinking)

You ever get that weird internal spiral where you’re like, “God, if that was You, blink twice”? And then you wait for a thunderclap, a dove to descend, or your Spotify shuffle to prophetically land on Oceans?

Same.

I’ve gone entire weeks, months, in a borderline mental breakdown loop trying to decode whether a random intrusive thought about moving to Iceland was God, the devil, or just my dehydrated brain on 3 hours of sleep and 2 iced coffees. At some point, I even tried casting lots with my laundry (don’t ask).

Hearing God shouldn’t feel like hacking into the Pentagon. But let’s admit it: for many of us Christian overthinkers, it does.

Why is hearing God so hard sometimes?

Honestly? Because we’re scared to get it wrong. We don’t want to embarrass ourselves, mislead others, or make a stupid life choice and slap a “God told me” sticker on it. And beneath that fear, there’s this ache to be loved well by Him. If I can just hear His voice clearly, I’ll feel safe, right? Directed. Wanted. Covered. Like He’s near.

But when we don’t hear Him, it’s like… “Hello? Jesus? Are You ghosting me?” And that makes us spiral more. Enter: Christian overthinking. We start praying about whether we should pray about praying. We analyze the tone of a sermon like we’re decoding Morse code. We wait for “peace,” but peace never arrives because we’ve turned “hearing God” into a spiritual math equation we’re constantly failing.

What if He’s actually speaking, just not in your preferred format?

See, here’s what I’ve noticed. God’s voice isn’t always audible, but it is personal. It’s less Siri, more Shepherd. Sometimes He’ll speak through Scripture, sometimes through people (yes, even that random TikTok you scrolled past at 3am), sometimes through that gut-stirring conviction that won’t shut up until you finally quit the job you prayed to get in the first place.

But here’s the kicker: it’s not always about clarity. Sometimes it’s about closeness. We don’t hear Him because we’re trying to solve Him. We treat His voice like it’s a map to a buried treasure instead of a relationship. The goal isn’t to “get it right”, it’s to walk with Him even when we’re unsure.

And fun fact: God has never once asked you to be 100% sure. That’s a you thing.

How I stopped trying to make every cloud formation a prophetic symbol

I remember this one church member who swore she heard the audible voice of God in her room. Like, full-volume, surround-sound Jesus. She talked about it so casually too, like, “Oh yeah, I heard God's audible voice,” while I’m over here struggling to discern whether I should reply to a text or flee the country. I mean, I love the Lord, but all I’m getting in my room is the sound of the fan and my own spiraling thoughts.

For a while, I genuinely thought I just wasn’t “spiritual enough.” Like maybe I didn’t pray hard enough, or fast long enough, or own enough worship playlists. But eventually I realized, no, I was just scared. Scared of doing it wrong. Scared of missing God. Scared He’d give up on me if I didn’t nail the landing the first time. I didn’t trust that He could guide me while I was moving. I thought I had to be this ultra-tuned, always-on Christian radio antenna before He’d even consider speaking.

But that’s not how God works.

He speaks in motion. You take a step, He meets you there. You fumble the step, He still walks with you. You misunderstand, overthink, pick the wrong city or job or yes or no, and He doesn’t throw up His hands and go, “Welp, you blew it.” He’s not a passive-aggressive GPS that silently watches you spiral down a dead end. He’s a Shepherd. A good one. And He knows how to reroute.

So now, when I’m unsure, I don’t get paralyzed. I pray, I ask, I move. Slowly, prayerfully, but with open hands. I give God full permission to interrupt me, and spoiler: sometimes He does. But I don’t live in fear of missteps anymore, because I finally trust this: He’s better at leading than I am at hearing. And He’s not out here trying to trick me.

Overthinking is not discernment (and the Holy Spirit doesn’t sound like anxiety)

This one took me a while to get. I used to call my panic “discernment.” I’d pace around, do the whole “fleece before God” thing, and think my mental agony was spiritual maturity. Spoiler: it wasn’t. It was fear.

The voice of God does not come with panic attacks and decision paralysis. He speaks with peace, even when the message is challenging. His voice brings clarity, not confusion. Even His No feels oddly kind.

If you’re drowning in spirals, chances are high that you’re not actually listening for God’s voice, you’re trying to control the outcome. You want to guarantee you won’t mess up, so you over-process, over-analyze, and over-spiritualize. You don’t want to hear God, you want to hear Him say what you already decided is safe.

And hey, no judgment. I’ve literally asked for a sign and then asked for a confirmation of that sign. And then one more confirmation… just in case.

So, how do you hear God? Like, actually?

Here’s what I’ve learned through painful trial, error, and crying into my worship playlist:

You already know how to hear Him. You just don’t trust that it’s Him.

He’s already speaking through the Word, through His Spirit in you, through your circumstances, through people. You just doubt that He would speak to you. You think you need to be holier, quieter, better. You think your overthinking disqualifies you from hearing Him.

But it doesn’t.

What if you stopped demanding a dramatic encounter and started stewarding the stillness?
What if you opened your Bible and believed the God who inspired those words still whispers to hearts today?
What if you stopped waiting for a billboard and started walking in faith, trusting He’d reroute you if needed?

You’d probably start hearing Him everywhere.

When it still feels like silence

Sometimes God doesn’t speak because He’s already spoken. He’s waiting on you to obey the last word before He gives you a new one. Other times, it’s not silence. It’s your soul being too loud to hear. You’ve got to quiet your own expectations, fears, and timelines to notice the whisper.

And sometimes? Sometimes it’s just a season of trust. He’s near. He’s working. But He’s letting you walk by faith, not sight. Not because He’s cruel, but because He’s growing something deeper in you than just the ability to hear. He’s teaching you to trust.

✦ ✦ ✦

FAQ

Q: How do I know if it's God's voice or my thoughts?

A: God’s voice is often marked by peace, clarity, and alignment with Scripture, even if what He says is challenging. If the message leads you toward humility, love, faith, or obedience, it's likely Him. Your own thoughts tend to spiral with fear, pressure, or confusion. God doesn’t rush, guilt-trip, or contradict His Word. When in doubt, weigh it against the Bible and His character.

That said, distinguishing between your inner dialogue and God’s whisper takes time and relationship. The more you walk with Him: through prayer, the Word, and stillness; the more familiar His voice becomes. Think of it less like a lightning bolt and more like tuning your ear over time. If you’re honestly seeking Him and open to correction, trust that He can lead you, even through your messy, human thoughts.

Q: Can you have a conversation with God without praying?

A: Yes, you can have a conversation with God without a formal, structured prayer. God is always present and listening, whether you're speaking out loud, thinking quietly, journaling, or even just sitting in silence with Him. Prayer isn’t about perfect words, it’s about connection. Talking to God can happen anywhere, anytime, in any form.

That said, prayer is still the primary way we intentionally engage with Him. But don’t get hung up on the format. God isn’t checking grammar or posture, He’s listening to your heart. Whether it’s a whispered “help” at a red light or a deep inner wrestle you haven’t even verbalized, He hears it all. The conversation doesn't end when you say "amen." In fact, sometimes it’s just beginning.

Q: What to do when you don't feel like praying or reading the Bible?

A: When you don’t feel like praying or reading the Bible, start small and be honest with God about it. He’s not intimidated by your lack of motivation. Even a one-sentence prayer like “God, I don’t want to pray right now” is a prayer. Sometimes showing up tired and unmotivated is more powerful than showing up perfectly. Just crack the door open, He’ll meet you there.

Spiritual dryness doesn’t disqualify you; it deepens your need. Try reading one verse instead of a chapter. Put on worship music. Journal your thoughts, even if they’re messy. God desires connection, not performance. And often, once you begin, even half-heartedly, your heart catches up. The key isn’t to force a feeling; it’s to keep showing up, even when it’s awkward.

Relevant Reads from the Blog

✦ ✦ ✦

Your Turn to Share

Have you ever heard God in a totally unexpected way? Or maybe you’re in a season where you feel like Heaven’s on mute? I’d love to know how you navigate it. Drop your thoughts below and let’s wrestle (and laugh) through it together.

And hey, next time you’re spiraling about whether to take that job, text that person, or move to a new city… take a breath. Ask God. Wait a moment. And then walk forward knowing this:
He’s a lot better at leading than you are at following. And that’s very good news.

Search This Blog

Seen and Understood: For the Quiet Ones With Loud Inner Worlds