Why Do Christian Girls Keep Catching Feelings for Emotionally Unavailable Guys?

“He Sends Bible Verses But Can’t Say ‘I Like You’"

Let’s just say it, emotionally unavailable guys are the spiritual version of junk food. Looks holy. Smells divine. Tastes like potential. But spiritually… gives you a stomachache.

You’re a Christian girl. You love Jesus, Hillsong's older albums, and the idea of a man who prays before making decisions. So why, oh why, do you find yourself overanalyzing a guy who won’t even call you his friend in public?

Let’s break this pattern down, one awkward worship night crush at a time.

1. He’s Broken… But With a Bible

Some Christian girls have a serious case of "fix-it faith."
You know the type: “He just needs someone to love him back to life.”
Cue soft piano worship music.

But sis… you’re not the Holy Spirit.
You're not the emotional paramedic for men who ghost you for three days and then randomly send you Psalm 23.

We romanticize brokenness because Christian culture often glorifies the “wounded leader” narrative. But unless he’s actively in healing, all you’re doing is dating someone who’s processing trauma out loud... and using you as the Kleenex.

2. He’s Mysterious = “He’s Deep”

Girl, he’s not mysterious. He’s just emotionally constipated.
But because he rarely opens up, you imagine there’s a sea of biblical depth underneath.

Nope. That’s not mystery. That’s avoidance.

He’s not “guarding his heart”, he’s hiding behind a wall of spiritual lingo and calling it discernment. And somehow, that makes you want him more.

Because if you could be the one he finally opens up to? Boom. Wife status unlocked.

Except you’re not his girlfriend. You’re his therapeutic safety net in the DMs.

3. You Mistake Chemistry for Calling

You’re at church. He walks in late, hoodie on, hands raised, eyes closed.
He loves Jesus and wears Nikes. You’re done for.

You feel something, so it must be confirmation.
Goosebumps = green light, right?

But here’s the thing: emotional unavailability feels familiar to those who didn’t see healthy intimacy modeled.
It feels like a “challenge,” not a relationship.

You crave the chase. You confuse anxiety with excitement.
Sis, that’s not God. That’s cortisol.

4. **He Has Just Enough Godliness to Keep You Hooked**

He’ll pray with you but won’t define the relationship.
He’ll repost Christian quotes but avoid real conversations.
He’ll flirt in group chats, then pull back and say, “I’m just focusing on God right now.”

Weaponized holiness is real.

He’s emotionally unavailable but spiritually breadcrumbing you.
You’re not in a relationship, you’re in a situationship with Jesus as the third wheel.

5. You’re Attracted to the Idea of Being Chosen

Let’s get real for a second:
Sometimes we chase emotionally unavailable guys because if they choose us, it feels like a bigger win.

You see other girls trying to get his attention, too.
You think, If he picks me, it means I’m special.

But God doesn’t love you based on how “pickable” you are.
He chose you before you had makeup on and while you were still texting your ex.
You don’t need a half-healed man to validate your worth.

6. You’re Spiritually Mature… But Emotionally Starving

You read your Bible. You journal. You lead small group.
But deep down, you’re lonely.

And loneliness is dangerous. It makes you settle.
It makes you romanticize potential over patterns.

An emotionally unavailable guy gives just enough attention to keep your hope on life support.
But hope without reality is a trap.

7. You Think God Sent Him as a “Project”

You’re like:
“He’s struggling, but I think God sent me to help him grow.”

No He didn’t.

God isn’t handing out romantic mission assignments like,
“Daughter, this one’s broken. Go fix him in My name.”

You’re not a rehab facility. You’re a daughter of the King.
Stop mistaking spiritual burden for romantic compatibility.

8. **He’s Unavailable Because You Are Emotionally Unavailable Too**

Mic drop.

Sometimes we chase people who won’t open up… because we’re scared to be vulnerable too.

If you pick someone who’s emotionally safe, you’ll have to actually show up fully.
No performance. No mystery. Just real, raw you.

And that’s terrifying.

So you chase emotionally unavailable guys because they’ll never really see you either.

✦ ✦ ✦

What’s the Godly Way Out of This Cycle?

You have to renew your standards, not just your feelings.
God didn’t call you to survive romantic confusion. He called you to walk in peace, clarity, and truth.

Yes, even in dating.

Here’s how to break free:

✅ 1. Pause Before the Pattern Starts

Next time you feel yourself getting butterflies for a guy who gives you nothing but mixed signals, pause.

Ask:

Is this peace or panic?
Is he pursuing me or confusing me?
Would I tell my future daughter to entertain this?

If it’s not clear, it’s a no.

✅ 2. **Define What Emotionally Available Looks Like**

It’s not just someone who talks a lot.
It’s someone who:

Shares feelings consistently
Owns their past without oversharing
Knows how to apologize
Doesn’t use prayer as a smoke screen
Pursues clarity, not confusion

Jesus said, “Let your yes be yes.” Not “let your yes be ‘I’ll pray about it’ for 3 months.”

✅ 3. Heal What Makes You Chase Confusion

This isn’t about blaming yourself, it’s about freeing yourself.

Sit with God. Ask:

“Why do I crave people who don’t show up for me?”

You might be surprised by what He reveals.
Healing comes when you stop looking at men for answers only God can give.

✅ 4. Let God Show You How Loved You Already Are

You don’t need to earn love from someone who can barely text you back.

You’re already loved:

Without chasing
Without competing
Without emotional games

Jesus doesn’t breadcrumb. He shows up fully, every time.

Let that be your new dating standard.

✦ ✦ ✦

FAQs

Q: How to tell if a Christian guy is interested in you or just being friendly?

A: A Christian guy who’s interested in you will make his intentions clear through consistent, intentional actions. He’ll seek you out, initiate conversations, and show a desire to spend time with you one-on-one, not just in group settings. He’ll communicate with purpose, follow through on his words, and often include you in his spiritual life (like praying with or for you). If you're confused or constantly guessing, that’s usually a sign he’s just being friendly, or worse, passively leading you on without commitment.

Beyond the basics, a guy who’s truly interested will create clarity, not confusion. He won’t leave you spiraling after every interaction or ghost you in the name of “waiting on God.” Instead, he’ll pursue emotional connection and honor your time. If he’s truly following Christ, his interest in you will reflect godly love: intentional, respectful, and not self-serving. So don’t settle for mixed signals, clarity is Christlike.

Q: How does a guy act when he's emotionally unavailable?

A: An emotionally unavailable guy often sends mixed signals, he may be charming one moment and distant the next. He avoids deep conversations, deflects vulnerability with humor or silence, and struggles to express how he truly feels. You’ll likely feel confused, unsure where you stand, and constantly trying to “decode” his behavior. If you're always initiating or feel like you're chasing emotional crumbs, he's likely not in a place to connect on a meaningful level.

On a deeper level, emotionally unavailable men may use busyness, spirituality, or even flirtation to avoid intimacy while still keeping you around. They might say things like “I’m not ready for a relationship” but still act like they’re halfway dating you. Instead of consistency and pursuit, you get hot-and-cold behavior, spiritual excuses, and emotional evasion. It’s not your job to crack the code. When a guy is ready and available, it shows.

Q: Can you like someone but be emotionally unavailable?

A: Yes, it’s completely possible to like someone and still be emotionally unavailable. You can feel genuine attraction, admiration, or even affection for a person, but if you're not in a place to open up, commit, or engage in emotional intimacy, that “like” never fully translates into a healthy relationship. Emotional unavailability blocks connection, even when the feelings are real.

Often, emotionally unavailable people carry unresolved wounds, fear vulnerability, or lack the emotional tools to show up fully. They might care deeply but still shut down, pull away, or send mixed signals when things start getting real. Liking someone isn’t the same as being ready to love them well. So if their actions don’t align with their feelings, it’s not always manipulation, it might just be emotional limitation.

Relevant Reads

✦ ✦ ✦

Let’s Hear It

Ever found yourself emotionally investing in a guy who can’t even commit to a lunch plan? What helped you finally walk away, or are you still in it? Share your story below, we read every one.

Search This Blog

Seen and Understood: For the Quiet Ones With Loud Inner Worlds